As a part of a series of short biographies on generals
published by Thomas Nelson, Sherman: The Ruthless Victor serves as basic
introduction to the famous (infamous?) Union Civil War general William Tecumseh
Sherman. Authors von Hassel and Breslin make Sherman
accessible as a person, filling out details of his upbringing and experiences
of life outside the military and Civil War years. However, the content is heavily tilted
towards his life before and during the war, with very little space given to
what he did after the conclusion of the war.
As I understand the purpose of this entire series on generals, this book
fares well enough – it is certainly written to engage the non-expert and introduce
readers to a well-known person without too much focus on military strategy or battles. Neither author is an academic historian of
the Civil War, which perhaps helps them to focus on understanding the
person. However, even as a general
introduction, I believe it would have benefited from at least nominal use of
primary source material for substantiation of claims, or even just to give an
idea to the reader of how General Sherman thought and wrote. There is no quote from Sherman in the whole
book longer than a phrase of a few words (and neither are there any footnotes
to help people track down more information on a certain topic, although there
is a brief bibliography). All in all,
this biography is a sufficient, but plain, introduction to a very interesting
person. Note: this book was provided for review
courtesy of booksneeze.com.
0 comments:
Post a Comment